Is personality profiling harming your EDI efforts?

3 Minutes
There is a documentary on HBO/Sky called: Persona: The Dark Truth About Personality Tests. What it highlights is examined.
  • According to Richard Thompson, Senior Director of Global Research, The Myers-Briggs Company, there is: "No reason to assume that a person with one particular type preference can do a job better than someone with another type preference." He said that it should not be used for hiring and Myers-Briggs has stopped selling to organisations who insist on doing this.
  • There is a belief that personality profiling favours extroverts for senior leadership positions.
  • There is a belief that personality profiling is biased against people with mental health issues (it can 'red flag' them as people not to recruit).
  • There is a belief that personality profiling is biased towards the group of people it was originally tested upon.
  • People are being coached to 'beat the system' and not tell the truth in the tests to try to increase their job prospects.

Personality Profiling is a multi-billion-dollar business, but given the above, should it really have such an influence over who gets a job or a promotion? Are the tests limited in their scope? Do they take enough into account that people can flex their behaviours? Many organisations will, of course, use the profiling as just one aspect of recruitment (even though Myers-Briggs don’t recommend this) or to decide who to promote but it is assumed it would be very difficult to ignore a red flag from the results.

The power of understanding your employee’s intrinsic motivators

Many of our clients at Brand Experiences are utilising mojo – our motivation and productivity platform – to understand their employees and to drive their productivity efforts. We believe that focusing on people’s intrinsic motivators is a vital aspect towards the success or failure of someone’s experience at work. Mojo doesn’t care about someone’s background, gender, age or religious beliefs; it’s a self-inventory which helps the employee and their line manager understand what motivates them. With the idea that if someone’s main intrinsic motivators are being met, they will be more productive, happier and will feel that what’s important to them is important to the organisation.

We believe that understanding someone’s motivation preferences is a good guide to role suitability. For example, if someone is motivated by money and materialism (the Builder) they’re unlikely to be satisfied in a role in frontline care; whereas someone motivated by finding meaning in their work (the Searcher) and enjoying fruitful working relationships (the Friend) is more likely to.

Personality Profiling has its place, but if you want a deeper understanding of what gets your employees out of bed in the morning and support for how to satisfy their intrinsic motivators to enable them to be more productive, then mojo is your go-to tool.

If you’d like to understand more about mojo, click here.

Hudhaib Al-Allatti
Hudhaib Al-Allatti
Co-founder 12 Events & Managing Director ProMedia International

Nicholas made an indispensable contribution to our Diversity & Inclusion summit. His insightful concepts, compelling presentation approach, and authentic enthusiasm for the Employee Experience topic significantly resonated with everyone, leaving a lasting impression on our entire audience.

Related Insights

Why do Employee Experience initiatives fall short?

Why is such a simple concept proving so hard to bring to life for organisations?
3 Minutes

You can’t content your way to EDI success

Simply posting articles about Black History Month or Pride Month does not make you an inclusive employer.
3 Minutes

How to write an Employee Experience strategy

Setting the route for your journey to EX success.
2 Minutes

Employee Experience EXplained #8: Why do we need Empathy Maps

In the eighth in the series, Nicholas Wardle discusses the numerous benefits of utilising Empathy Maps.
2 Minutes 27/11/2023

How Does Organisational Culture Shape Employee Behavior and Business Outcomes?

Organizational culture is a multifaceted concept that goes beyond a mere catchphrase; it's the essence that permeates every aspect of an employee's experience within a company. This essence influences how employees approach their work, interact with colleagues, and perceive their role in achieving the organization's goals. While defining organizational culture conceptually is straightforward, understanding how it manifests in tangible employee behaviors and business outcomes is more complex. This complexity arises because organizational culture is not static; it's a dynamic force that evolves in response to external factors, leadership changes, and market shifts. This adaptability is crucial in shaping employee behavior and business outcomes. The upcoming sections will delve deeper into how organizational culture exerts this influence, providing scientific insights and real-world examples.

Would you like to speak to one of our experts?